Introduction To The Literature Review Assignment

DNP 820 Week 4: Introduction to the Literature Review Assignment

DNP 820 Week 4: Introduction to the Literature Review Assignment

Part 1: Selection of 15 Articles

Empirical Research Checklist

Article 1: Ghouri, F., Hollywood, A., & Ryan, K. (2018). A systematic review of non-antibiotic measures for the prevention of urinary tract infections in pregnancy. BMC pregnancy and childbirth, 18(1), 99. DOI: 10.1186/s12884-018-1732-2.

Section	Defining Characteristic	Contained in Article	Not Contained in Article
Abstract	An abstract of the contents is provided.	Yes
Introduction	The purpose of the study is stated.	Yes
	The scope of the study is stated.	Yes
	A rationale for the study is provided.	Yes
	The hypothesis or research question is stated.		Yes
	Key concepts and terms are noted.	Yes
	A review of the literature is provided.	Yes
Methods	A description of the population sample is provided.	Yes
	The data collection procedure is presented.	Yes
	Other procedures to be used are described.	Yes
Results	A narrative statement of the findings is given.	Yes
	A description of the data collected is given.	Yes
	Findings are supported by graphs and charts.	Yes
	The analysis of the data is explained.	Yes
Conclusion	A summary of the study is provided.	Yes
	Conclusions related to the hypothesis are stated.	Yes
	Questions for future research are presented.	Yes
References	References used in the study are presented.	Yes

Article 2: García-Larrosa, A., & Alexe, O. (2016). Efficacy and Safety of a Medical Device versus Placebo in the Early Treatment of Patients with Symptoms of Urinary Tract Infection: A Randomized Controlled Trial. Clin Microbiol 5: 233. doi: 10.4172/2327-5073.1000233 Page 2 of 5 Clin Microbiol ISSN: 2327-5073 CMO, an open access journal Volume 5• Issue 1• 1000233. Figure, 1, 3. DOI: 10.4172/2327-5073.1000233.

Section	Defining Characteristic	Contained in Article	Not Contained in Article
Abstract	An abstract of the contents is provided.	Yes
Introduction	The purpose of the study is stated.	Yes
	The scope of the study is stated.	Yes
	A rationale for the study is provided.	Yes
	The hypothesis or research question is stated.	Yes
	Key concepts and terms are noted.	Yes
	A review of the literature is provided.		Yes
Methods	A description of the population sample is provided.	Yes
	The data collection procedure is presented.	Yes
	Other procedures to be used are described.		Yes
Results	A narrative statement of the findings is given.	Yes
	A description of the data collected is given.	Yes
	Findings are supported by graphs and charts.		Yes
	The analysis of the data is explained.	Yes
Conclusion	A summary of the study is provided.	Yes
	Conclusions related to the hypothesis are stated.	Yes
	Questions for future research are presented.	Yes
References	References used in the study are presented.	Yes

Article 3: Bosmans, J. E., Beerepoot, M. A., Prins, J. M., ter Riet, G., & Geerlings, S. E. (2014). Cost-effectiveness of cranberries vs antibiotics to prevent urinary tract infections in premenopausal women: a randomized clinical trial. PloS one, 9(4), e91939. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0091939.

Section	Defining Characteristic	Contained in Article	Not Contained in Article
Abstract	An abstract of the contents is provided.	Yes
Introduction	The purpose of the study is stated.	Yes
	The scope of the study is stated.	Yes
	A rationale for the study is provided.	Yes
	The hypothesis or research question is stated.	Yes
	Key concepts and terms are noted.	Yes
	A review of the literature is provided.	Yes
Methods	A description of the population sample is provided.	Yes
	The data collection procedure is presented.	Yes
	Other procedures to be used are described.	Yes
Results	A narrative statement of the findings is given.	Yes
	A description of the data collected is given.	Yes
	Findings are supported by graphs and charts.		Yes
	The analysis of the data is explained.	Yes
Conclusion	A summary of the study is provided.	Yes
	Conclusions related to the hypothesis are stated.	Yes
	Questions for future research are presented.	Yes
References	References used in the study are presented.	Yes

Article 4: Kronenberg, A., Bütikofer, L., Odutayo, A., Mühlemann, K., da Costa, B. R., Battaglia, M., … & Jüni, P. (2017). Symptomatic treatment of uncomplicated lower urinary tract infections in the ambulatory setting: randomised, double blind trial. bmj, 359, j4784. DOI: 10.1136/bmj.j4784.

Section	Defining Characteristic	Contained in Article	Not Contained in Article
Abstract	An abstract of the contents is provided.	Yes
Introduction	The purpose of the study is stated.	Yes
	The scope of the study is stated.	Yes
	A rationale for the study is provided.	Yes
	The hypothesis or research question is stated.	Yes
	Key concepts and terms are noted.		Yes
	A review of the literature is provided.	Yes
Methods	A description of the population sample is provided.	Yes
	The data collection procedure is presented.	Yes
	Other procedures to be used are described.		Yes
Results	A narrative statement of the findings is given.	Yes
	A description of the data collected is given.	Yes
	Findings are supported by graphs and charts.	Yes
	The analysis of the data is explained.	Yes
Conclusion	A summary of the study is provided.	Yes
	Conclusions related to the hypothesis are stated.	Yes
	Questions for future research are presented.	Yes
References	References used in the study are presented.	Yes

Article 5: Beerepoot, M., & Geerlings, S. (2016). Non-antibiotic prophylaxis for urinary tract infections. Pathogens, 5(2), 36. DOI: 10.3390/pathogens5020036.

Section	Defining Characteristic	Contained in Article	Not Contained in Article
Abstract	An abstract of the contents is provided.	Yes
Introduction	The purpose of the study is stated.	Yes
	The scope of the study is stated.	Yes
	A rationale for the study is provided.	Yes
	The hypothesis or research question is stated.	Yes
	Key concepts and terms are noted.	Yes
	A review of the literature is provided.	Yes
Methods	A description of the population sample is provided.	Yes
	The data collection procedure is presented.	Yes
	Other procedures to be used are described.		Yes
Results	A narrative statement of the findings is given.	Yes
	A description of the data collected is given.	Yes
	Findings are supported by graphs and charts.	Yes
	The analysis of the data is explained.	Yes
Conclusion	A summary of the study is provided.	Yes
	Conclusions related to the hypothesis are stated.	Yes
	Questions for future research are presented.	Yes
References	References used in the study are presented.	Yes

Article 6: Geerlings, S. E., Beerepoot, M. A., & Prins, J. M. (2014). Prevention of recurrent urinary tract infections in women: antimicrobial and nonantimicrobial strategies. Infectious Disease Clinics, 28(1), 135-147. DOI: 10.1016/j.idc.2013.10.001.

Section	Defining Characteristic	Contained in Article	Not Contained in Article
Abstract	An abstract of the contents is provided.	Yes
Introduction	The purpose of the study is stated.	Yes
	The scope of the study is stated.	Yes
	A rationale for the study is provided.	Yes
	The hypothesis or research question is stated.		Yes
	Key concepts and terms are noted.	Yes
	A review of the literature is provided.		Yes
Methods	A description of the population sample is provided.	Yes
	The data collection procedure is presented.	Yes
	Other procedures to be used are described.	Yes
Results	A narrative statement of the findings is given.	Yes
	A description of the data collected is given.	Yes
	Findings are supported by graphs and charts.		Yes
	The analysis of the data is explained.	Yes
Conclusion	A summary of the study is provided.	Yes
	Conclusions related to the hypothesis are stated.	Yes
	Questions for future research are presented.	Yes
References	References used in the study are presented.	Yes

Article 7: Costantini, E., Giannitsas, K., & Illiano, E. (2017). The role of nonantibiotic treatment of community-acquired urinary tract infections. Current opinion in urology, 27(2), 120-126. DOI: 10.1097/MOU.0000000000000366.

Section	Defining Characteristic	Contained in Article	Not Contained in Article
Abstract	An abstract of the contents is provided.	Yes
Introduction	The purpose of the study is stated.	Yes
	The scope of the study is stated.	Yes
	A rationale for the study is provided.	Yes
	The hypothesis or research question is stated.		Yes
	Key concepts and terms are noted.	Yes
	A review of the literature is provided.	Yes
Methods	A description of the population sample is provided.	Yes
	The data collection procedure is presented.	Yes
	Other procedures to be used are described.	Yes
Results	A narrative statement of the findings is given.	Yes
	A description of the data collected is given.	Yes
	Findings are supported by graphs and charts.		Yes
	The analysis of the data is explained.	Yes
Conclusion	A summary of the study is provided.	Yes
	Conclusions related to the hypothesis are stated.	Yes
	Questions for future research are presented.	Yes
References	References used in the study are presented.	Yes

Article 8: Luís, Â., Domingues, F., & Pereira, L. (2017). Can cranberries contribute to reduce the incidence of urinary tract infections? A systematic review with meta-analysis and trial sequential analysis of clinical trials. The Journal of urology, 198(3), 614-621. DOI: 10.1016/j.juro.2017.03.078.

Section	Defining Characteristic	Contained in Article	Not Contained in Article
Abstract	An abstract of the contents is provided.	Yes
Introduction	The purpose of the study is stated.	Yes
	The scope of the study is stated.	Yes
	A rationale for the study is provided.	Yes
	The hypothesis or research question is stated.	Yes
	Key concepts and terms are noted.	Yes
	A review of the literature is provided.		Yes
Methods	A description of the population sample is provided.	Yes
	The data collection procedure is presented.	Yes
	Other procedures to be used are described.	Yes
Results	A narrative statement of the findings is given.	Yes
	A description of the data collected is given.	Yes
	Findings are supported by graphs and charts.	Yes
	The analysis of the data is explained.	Yes
Conclusion	A summary of the study is provided.	Yes
	Conclusions related to the hypothesis are stated.	Yes
	Questions for future research are presented.	Yes
References	References used in the study are presented.	Yes

Article 9: Kim, K. H. (2014). Non-Antibiotic Prophylaxis for Recurrent Urinary Tract Infections. The Korean Journal of Urogenital Tract Infection and Inflammation, 9(1), 9-13. DOI: 10.14777/kjutii.2014.9.1.9.

Section	Defining Characteristic	Contained in Article	Not Contained in Article
Abstract	An abstract of the contents is provided.	Yes
Introduction	The purpose of the study is stated.	Yes
	The scope of the study is stated.	Yes
	A rationale for the study is provided.	Yes
	The hypothesis or research question is stated.		Yes
	Key concepts and terms are noted.		Ye
	A review of the literature is provided.	Yes
Methods	A description of the population sample is provided.	Yes
	The data collection procedure is presented.	Yes
	Other procedures to be used are described.
Results	A narrative statement of the findings is given.	Yes
	A description of the data collected is given.	Yes
	Findings are supported by graphs and charts.		Yes
	The analysis of the data is explained.	Yes
Conclusion	A summary of the study is provided.	Yes
	Conclusions related to the hypothesis are stated.	Yes
	Questions for future research are presented.	Yes
References	References used in the study are presented.	Yes

Article 10: Occhipinti, A., Germano, A., & Maffei, M. E. (2016). Prevention of urinary tract infection with Oximacro®, a cranberry extract with a high content of a-type proanthocyanidins: A pre-clinical double-blind controlled study. Urology journal, 13(2), 2640-2649. DOI: 10.1029.uj/article/view/3190.

Section	Defining Characteristic	Contained in Article	Not Contained in Article
Abstract	An abstract of the contents is provided.	Yes
Introduction	The purpose of the study is stated.	Yes
	The scope of the study is stated.	Yes
	A rationale for the study is provided.	Yes
	The hypothesis or research question is stated.	Yes
	Key concepts and terms are noted.	Yes
	A review of the literature is provided.	Yes
Methods	A description of the population sample is provided.	Yes
	The data collection procedure is presented.	Yes
	Other procedures to be used are described.	Yes
Results	A narrative statement of the findings is given.	Yes
	A description of the data collected is given.	Yes
	Findings are supported by graphs and charts.	Yes
	The analysis of the data is explained.	Yes
Conclusion	A summary of the study is provided.	Yes
	Conclusions related to the hypothesis are stated.	Yes
	Questions for future research are presented.		Yes
References	References used in the study are presented.	Yes

Article 11: Gágyor, I., Bleidorn, J., Kochen, M. M., Schmiemann, G., Wegscheider, K., & Hummers-Pradier, E. (2015). Ibuprofen versus fosfomycin for uncomplicated urinary tract infection in women: randomized controlled trial. bmj, 351, h6544. DOI: 10.1136/bmj.h6544.

Section	Defining Characteristic	Contained in Article	Not Contained in Article
Abstract	An abstract of the contents is provided.	Yes
Introduction	The purpose of the study is stated.	Yes
	The scope of the study is stated.	Yes
	A rationale for the study is provided.	Yes
	The hypothesis or research question is stated.	Yes
	Key concepts and terms are noted.	Yes
	A review of the literature is provided.	Yes
Methods	A description of the population sample is provided.	Yes
	The data collection procedure is presented.	Yes
	Other procedures to be used are described.		Yes
Results	A narrative statement of the findings is given.	Yes
	A description of the data collected is given.	Yes
	Findings are supported by graphs and charts.	Yes
	The analysis of the data is explained.	Yes
Conclusion	A summary of the study is provided.	Yes
	Conclusions related to the hypothesis are stated.	Yes
	Questions for future research are presented.	Yes
References	References used in the study are presented.	Yes

Article 12: Behzadi, P. (2018). Introductory Chapter: An Overview on Urinary Tract Infections, Pathogens, and Risk Factors. In Microbiology of Urinary Tract Infections: Microbial Agents and Predisposing Factors. IntechOpen. DOI: 10.5772/intechopen.82230.

Section	Defining Characteristic	Contained in Article	Not Contained in Article
Abstract	An abstract of the contents is provided.		Yes
Introduction	The purpose of the study is stated.	Yes
	The scope of the study is stated.	Yes
	A rationale for the study is provided.		Yes
	The hypothesis or research question is stated.		Yes
	Key concepts and terms are noted.	Yes
	A review of the literature is provided.		Yes
Methods	A description of the population sample is provided.		Yes
	The data collection procedure is presented.		Yes
	Other procedures to be used are described.		Yes
Results	A narrative statement of the findings is given.		Yes
	A description of the data collected is given.		Yes
	Findings are supported by graphs and charts.		Yes
	The analysis of the data is explained.		Yes
Conclusion	A summary of the study is provided.	Yes
	Conclusions related to the hypothesis are stated.	Yes
	Questions for future research are presented.	Yes
References	References used in the study are presented.	Yes

Article 13: Liska, D., Derrig, L., & Mah, E. (2018). Urinary Tract Infection: Should Cranberry and Probiotics Be Considered?. Nutrition Today, 53(5), 207-212. DOI: 10.1097/NT.0000000000000297.

Section	Defining Characteristic	Contained in Article	Not Contained in Article
Abstract	An abstract of the contents is provided.	Yes
Introduction	The purpose of the study is stated.	Yes
	The scope of the study is stated.	Yes
	A rationale for the study is provided.	Yes
	The hypothesis or research question is stated.		Yes
	Key concepts and terms are noted.		Yes
	A review of the literature is provided.	Yes
Methods	A description of the population sample is provided.	Yes
	The data collection procedure is presented.	Yes
	Other procedures to be used are described.		Yes
Results	A narrative statement of the findings is given.	Yes
	A description of the data collected is given.	Yes
	Findings are supported by graphs and charts.	Yes
	The analysis of the data is explained.	Yes
Conclusion	A summary of the study is provided.	Yes
	Conclusions related to the hypothesis are stated.	Yes
	Questions for future research are presented.		Yes
References	References used in the study are presented.	Yes

Article 14: Ng, Q. X., Peters, C., Venkatanarayanan, N., Goh, Y. Y., Ho, C. Y. X., & Yeo, W. S. (2018). Use of Lactobacillus spp. to prevent recurrent urinary tract infections in females. Medical hypotheses, 114, 49-54. DOI: 10.1016/j.mehy.2018.03.001.

Section	Defining Characteristic	Contained in Article	Not Contained in Article
Abstract	An abstract of the contents is provided.	Yes
Introduction	The purpose of the study is stated.	Yes
	The scope of the study is stated.	Yes
	A rationale for the study is provided.	Yes
	The hypothesis or research question is stated.	Yes
	Key concepts and terms are noted.	Yes
	A review of the literature is provided.	Yes
Methods	A description of the population sample is provided.	Yes
	The data collection procedure is presented.	Yes
	Other procedures to be used are described.	Yes
Results	A narrative statement of the findings is given.	Yes
	A description of the data collected is given.	Yes
	Findings are supported by graphs and charts.		Yes
	The analysis of the data is explained.	Yes
Conclusion	A summary of the study is provided.	Yes
	Conclusions related to the hypothesis are stated.	Yes
	Questions for future research are presented.	Yes
References	References used in the study are presented.	Yes

Article 15: Toh, S. L., Boswell‐Ruys, C. L., Lee, B. S. B., Simpson, J. M., & Clezy, K. R. (2017). Probiotics for preventing urinary tract infection in people with neuropathic bladder. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, (9). DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD.010723.pub2.

Section

Defining Characteristic

Contained in Article

Not Contained in Article

Grading Rubric Accomplished Emerging Unsatisfactory Content Points Range:62.25 (41.50%) – 75 (50.00%) Responds clearly, thoroughly, and effectively to all aspects of the assignment. All content is accurate and/or supported. Points Range:57 (38.00%) – 61.5 (41.00%) Responds adequately to the assignment but may not be thorough. Points Range:0 (0.00%) – 56.25 (37.50%) Does not respond to the assignment. Focus and Detail Points Range:31.125 (20.75%) – 37.5 (25.00%) There is a clear, well-focused topic. Main ideas are clear and are well supported by detailed and accurate information gathered from scholarly sources. Points Range:28.5 (19.00%) – 30.75 (20.50%) There is a clear, well-focused topic. Main ideas are clear but are not well supported by scholarly sources and detailed information. Points Range:0 (0.00%) – 28.125 (18.75%) The topic and main ideas are not clear. Organization Points Range:18.675 (12.45%) – 22.5 (15.00%) The introduction is inviting, states the main topic, and provides an overview of the paper. Information is relevant and presented in a logical order. The conclusion is strong. Points Range:17.1 (11.40%) – 18.45 (12.30%) The introduction states the main topic and provides an overview of the paper. A conclusion is included. Points Range:0 (0.00%) – 16.875 (11.25%) There is no clear introduction, structure, or conclusion. Mechanics and APA Points Range:12.45 (8.30%) – 15 (10.00%) The assignment consistently follows current APA format and is free of errors in formatting, citation, and references. There are no grammatical, spelling, or punctuation errors. All sources are correctly cited and referenced. Points Range:11.4 (7.60%) – 12.3 (8.20%) The assignment consistently follows current APA format with only isolated and inconsistent mistakes and/or has a few grammatical, spelling, or punctuation errors. Most sources are correctly cited and referenced. Points Range:0 (0.00%) – 11.25 (7.50%) The assignment does not follow current APA format and/or has many grammatical, spelling, or punctuation errors. Many sources are incorrectly cited and referenced or citations and references are missing.